Should You Repair or Replace Your Roof?

When your roof starts showing signs of wear and tear, you face a big decision: should you repair it or replace it entirely? This choice depends on several factors, from the extent of the damage to the age of your roof. Here’s a guide to help you make the best decision for your home.

Assess the Damage

First, you need to evaluate the condition of your roof. Common issues include:

  • Minor Damage: A few missing shingles or small leaks might just need a simple repair.
  • Moderate Damage: Widespread shingle damage, noticeable leaks, or small sections of sagging could go either way, repair or replacement.
  • Severe Damage: Large areas of missing shingles, significant water damage, or structural issues usually require a full replacement.

Consider the Age of Your Roof

The age of your roof is a crucial factor:

  • Newer Roofs (Under 10-15 Years): If your roof is relatively new, repairs are often more practical and cost-effective.
  • Older Roofs (Over 20 Years): For older roofs, especially those nearing the end of their expected lifespan, replacement is often the better long-term solution.

Evaluate the Cost

Cost is always a consideration:

  • Repair Costs: Repairs are typically less expensive in the short term. However, frequent repairs can add up over time.
  • Replacement Costs: A full replacement is a larger upfront investment but can save you money on ongoing repairs and improve your home’s value.

Think About Long-Term Solutions

When deciding between repair and replacement, consider the long-term benefits. Repairs may be good for minor issues and extending the life of a relatively new roof. However, if you have an older roof, there may be other issues.

While the new shingles used for replacement may match in size and function, there can be obvious issues with older, exposed shingles such as:

  • Dirt accumulation
  • Algae staining
  • Weathering and aging

Also the older shingles on the roof may no longer visually match extra shingles saved and stored from the time of the original installation.

There may be other conditions that may discourage replacing shingles on an older roof. These conditions are:

  • The older shingles may not be pliable or flexible enough to allow for selective repair or replacement.
  • Shingles manufactured at different manufacturing plants may have a different color hue, which could cause a more severe color discrepancy.
  • The shingle model’s current granule color blend may have a been modified since the original application. Mixing old and new blends on the same roof planes, especially from different manufacturer plants, may differ in color.
  • Some shingle models have been revised from “english” to “metric” dimensions. In those cases the older and newer shingles will not be dimensionally compatible.

Therefore, choosing a roof replacement offers peace of mind with a new warranty, better aesthetic appeal, increased energy efficiency, and potentially higher resale value for your home.

Impact on Home Value

A new roof can enhance your home’s curb appeal and market value:

  • Repair: Keeps your roof functional and can be less disruptive.
  • Replacement: A new roof can be a strong selling point if you’re considering putting your home on the market.

Energy Efficiency

New roofing materials are often more energy-efficient:

  • Repair: Might not improve energy efficiency much, especially if your roof is older.
  • Replacement: Modern roofing materials can better insulate your home, reducing energy bills.

Consult a Professional

Finally, it’s essential to get a professional opinion. A trusted roofer can provide a thorough inspection and recommend the best course of action based on the specific condition of your roof.


Deciding whether to repair or replace your roof depends on the extent of the damage, the age of your roof, and your long-term plans. Minor damage on a newer roof usually calls for repairs, while extensive damage or an older roof might be better off with a replacement. If you’re still unsure, give us a call. Our team can help you make the best decision for your home, ensuring you stay safe and dry for years to come. Contact us today for a thorough roof inspection and reliable repair service.

Leave a Comment

Review Us!

We’ve found that customer reviews are very helpful in keeping our business thriving. We would truly appreciate a review from you!

Select your preferred site to leave a review or comment. Options are listed below with direct links to our listing.

Review Robert Evans Jr. Contractor on Google
Review Robert Evans Jr. Contractor on Facebook
Review Robert Evans Jr. Contractor on Yelp
Review Robert Evans Jr. Contractor on Angi
Review Robert Evans Jr Contracting on HomeAdvisor